Need an honest review of your music from a team of 5? Welcome to The Consensus – group music reviews for all genres.
If you would like us to review your music, click here.
Latest Music Reviews
These are the latest 15 reviews that we've completed.
To read a review, click on the song name.
|
 |
Genre: Extreme Metal
|
|
nb gave a score of 6.33 / 10. Comments were:
The first half is a kindler, gentler extreme metal song that is melodic and pleasing in this surprisingly introspective song. The guitar harkens back to of all things Boston 70´s guitar rock band. Then when the intense growling death rasp and rapid speed is what one would expect in this genre and you deliver and submerge us all in dirt. Oh yes it has definite cinematic qualities as well... now time to sleep with my lights on.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6, Recording: 6, Freshness: 5, Vocals: 7, Musicianship: 8, XFactor: 7
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 7.62 / 10. Comments were:
"Disk.." something was unavailable for review so I clicked on "The autumn son." This is a rare treat, since I don't often hear this hard metal on the internet. But when the music is as fast as this, the drummer misses a few beats here and there. But no matter. This is up to par with many bands that sound like these guys. They handle their instruments well, and the vocals are well organized. I will actually go as far as to say Submerged in Dirt are more talented than many of the selected few I've heard that aren't speaking (screaming?) to a record label on a daily basis. For those of you who love the very hard metal, I can only recommend.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6.5, Recording: 5.5, Freshness: 9.5, XFactor: 9
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 10 / 10. Comments were:
Submerged in Dirt is like a submarine. Buried - unseen - never even notice it until it's just to late. Cept this submarine creeps up from the earth and just explodes all over the place. Your place, my place. It is however - an extreemly well disaplined explosiong. Ancestrial chiors - long buried in the earth emerge with that deep, resonating voice driving them on. AS TIGHT AS THE LIGHT - cept it's not about that. Most excellent at every level - qualifies for the Mongo Ungowa U award. Inner Primal 101. Bass, guitars, drums.. welcome to the School of Higher Throbbing...
WAY BEYOND THE BONEZ - MONGO FAR OUT...
Scoring: Songcraft: 10, Recording: 10, Freshness: 10, Vocals: 10, Musicianship: 10, XFactor: 10
|
Axeman gave a score of 4.6 / 10. Comments were:
Supposedly, SID wants to "create a new higher standard of metal". So, why does it start the first half of this song with a lame throwback to 80's melodic metal, complete with harmonized guitar solo and pointless pulloffs? I would excise the first 2 minutes of this song, the latter part of the song is much more energenic and entertaining, even if i still can't understand a word the singer's saying. Hey, now there's a thought guys--you wanna elevate death metal?--how bout recording a true death metal song that can actually be understood? Now, that would be original.
Scoring: Songcraft: 5, Recording: 6.5, Freshness: 4.5, Vocals: 1.5, Musicianship: 5.5, XFactor: 5.5
|
Nibbish gave a score of 6.1 / 10. Comments were:
For the first two minutes or so, this song has a nice progressive metal feel to it. A lightly growled vocal (if that makes any sense), some nice fretwork, some fairly simple, yet insistant drums. It slowly starts to devolve into insanity around the 2:15 mark, seeking to drag the listener with it. The vocalist pulls up his best demonic possession victim impression, and the band goes into coniptions. It goes through a couple of stages, slowing down a bit for each before launching into a truly impressive solo around the 4 minute mark. While the 'hardcore brutal metal' parts are almost a little buzzy (thus losing their power to a certain extent), they're nowhere near as mindlessly played as some that I've heard, and the band is obviously well-versed in creating songs. By the time the requisite haunting fadeout comes along, you're left with yet another song that thinks it's so much more hardcore than it actually is, but the begining is well worth the listen. It's very good.
Scoring: Songcraft: 7.5, Recording: 5, Freshness: 6, Vocals: 5.5, Musicianship: 9, XFactor: 6.5
|
 |
Genre: Indie Rock
|
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 7.87 / 10. Comments were:
The song in question was not available at the time, so I now review Stupid Girl. Reminds me a lot of the more happy songs of No Doubt. The song is kind of smart, because it actually borrows some inspiration from Drum'n base in the beat. Just a little, not much. It is not a Drum'n base beat, but still, it got some kick. The female vocals are very good, accompanied with a very well arranged guitar, and supporting instruments. The song is absolutely radio friendly, and very upbeat and happy. I find it hard, not to recommend the track, because the sound is so honest without using too much of the overrated distortion or other effects. So yeah, I recommend the song to anybody who like radio music, but just want something a bit different. Highly recommended.
Scoring: Songcraft: 8, Recording: 7.5, Freshness: 7.5, XFactor: 8.5
|
nb gave a score of 6.41 / 10. Comments were:
Great female vox, at the intro I though inocent and light like Jewel but when the heavier production came in she really held her own. Vocals are very pleasing and expressive. Musically the melody is strong and easy to remember. Iam not caryzy about the hook we mourn we mourn,,,and the lyrics some times are not cohesive. In first part it is written what seems third person or at least a universal stand point then it becomes more intimate and personal. The cynicism is about the lost love but it is not clear lyrically how you make that global jump to colour everything that way. Overall an enjoyable listen!
Scoring: Songcraft: 5, Recording: 6.5, Freshness: 6.5, Vocals: 8, Musicianship: 7, XFactor: 7
|
Andy Chapman gave a score of 6.5 / 10. Comments were:
If the 90's Australian outfit 'Frente' were dirtier and grungier, what you'd have is “The Lighting Strikes”. Lead vocalist Lacy Wright hits home with sugar sweet and strong vocals that are both melodious and pitch perfect. Backing her up is one-man-band Carter Stewart, who seems to play every damn instrument under the sun, and in convincing style. The recording is a little bass heavy for my liking and I think lacks a bit of polish. Other than that, this is a very solid offering and worth a listen.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6.5, Recording: 5.5, Freshness: 6.5, Vocals: 7.5, Musicianship: 7.5, XFactor: 6.5
|
Goat gave a score of 5.16 / 10. Comments were:
A weak beginning vocally does nothing to endear the listener to the stronger arrangement that follows. But then, the singer doesn't do anything to help herself either. Sliding into notes, over reaching intervals, trying for that damned octave jump that became popular and is now a cliche just doesn't make for a good presentation. As a producer, I would have strived for a better vocal performance. The rest of the track is kinda good and has some potential.
Scoring: Songcraft: 5.5, Recording: 7, Freshness: 5.5, Vocals: 3.5, Musicianship: 7, XFactor: 3.5
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 8.08 / 10. Comments were:
The Liking Strikes and The Liking Strikes. Where has this group been hiding? Somewhere that Bush can't find them because he couldn't handle the heat from this "Bush". Just excellent. Most original - great structure and this Girl has a set of pipes and knows how to use them. She weaves throughout the stucatto guitars and drums - perfect. Out of Ten Bonez - Mongo give three sevens
Scoring: Songcraft: 7, Recording: 7.5, Freshness: 7.5, Vocals: 9, Musicianship: 9, XFactor: 9
|
 |
Genre: Folk
|
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 3.75 / 10. Comments were:
The song starts very carefully. In fact, I wondered if there even was a song, so I had to turn up the volume. The song consists of two things: The very careful guitar playing, and the even more subtle vocalist. So this is folk music, and this will work very well by the campfire I'm sure. As an mp3 file, I am not so sure it works that well. BECAUSE there is also a third thing in this track. Yes I mentioned the guitar, and the guy singing. But there is also another band member not so talked about, but who we really should bring out in the spotlight: Silence. Because when the dude, and the guitar, are not doing anything, Mr. Silence steps in. Oh yes. Absolute silence. Nothing. Not even a hissing sound, and no hissing is usually a good thing (good record quality.) If I was sitting by the campfire with Dan Weintraub in person, I'm sure I'd close my eyes, and me and him could sit down after his little tune, and talk about the good old days, and have a smoke. Because this is great music! But Dan Weintraub is not with me, he is on my speakers. There is no campfire, because I don't want to burn my house down. So here I am, with my speakers, the man, and his guitar, and in between the pauses, we have Mr. Silence. Maybe I have misunderstood the song, or what Dan is trying to convey, maybe that is what it is. Because to me, this sounds like chunks of music, like a CD with many tracks and spaces in between. With the campfire sound which is so important to me, the song would make sense. Because this is a very acoustic song. But with the silences in between the guitar playing and the occasional singing, and the fact that this is not very loud at all, leaves me wondering if this is a rare case of folk music, on a collision course with technology. Maybe if this sounded more like a live recording, and not so digitally perfect as it is now, it wouldn't feel so wrong as it does.
Scoring: Songcraft: 5, Recording: 10, Freshness: 0, XFactor: 0
|
nb gave a score of 3.75 / 10. Comments were:
This could be the start of a real great song but it doesn’t go any where right now. There is no communication of your statement’s into their meaning. Lyrically you never tell us why we should be so negative ie reveling in the lows, talking about the despised, enthralled by the morose..etc. What is the pay off for the listener of doing what you say? The song at best self reflective introspective inner voice meanderings at worst a boring traverse into the darkside of depression. Musically it is repeats and is in desperate need of a chorus, a break or something to keep the listener engaged. Overall a work in progress with much potential.
Scoring: Songcraft: 4.5, Recording: 3, Freshness: 2, Vocals: 5.5, Musicianship: 5, XFactor: 2.5
|
Andy Chapman gave a score of 4.8 / 10. Comments were:
'Unuttered' is full of hiss and dirt and emptiness, but it's those raw elements that makes it seam pretty down to earth and real. You can picture Dan sitting in his room on some lonely Sunday afternoon recording this by himself. Dan's vocal delivery is sparse and to the point, reminding me a bit of Johnny Cash. All in all this is a pleasant and inoffensive folk tune, but it doesn't really hit a home run.
Scoring: Songcraft: 5, Recording: 3.5, Freshness: 5, Vocals: 6.5, Musicianship: 5, XFactor: 4
|
Goat gave a score of 5 / 10. Comments were:
Sorry to say I'm not terribly moved by this simple folk tune, voiced over the simplest of guitar strumming. Essentially, what Dan has given us to review is a songwriter demo -- bare of any substantive arrangment and production elements to bring the story to life. Good lyrics though.
Scoring: Songcraft: 5, Recording: 5, Freshness: 5, Vocals: 5, Musicianship: 5, XFactor: 3
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 7.5 / 10. Comments were:
Dan Weintraub remind Mong of a fella most of todays crowd never heard of. His name was - is - Leonard Cohen. Maybe Mongo not spell it right - but those of you who know - know. Dan be thinkin' and feelin' what he's saying. He's a good songwriter - not playing for the mainstream but playing what he knows. It is in tunes like "Unuttered" that the truth be found. But one has to be paying attention in the first place to get it at all. Out of ten bonez - Mongo give 72
Scoring: Songcraft: 8, Recording: 7, Freshness: 7, Vocals: 7.5, Musicianship: 7, XFactor: 7.5
|
 |
Genre: Pop
|
|
Goat gave a score of 4.16 / 10. Comments were:
i have a sense that somewhere in the future this young singer-songwriter will will find his way. Right now, today, based on this one track, I'd say he has a lot to learn yet. First, lyrically, this is not a folk song. It's a pop love song sung with a simply strummed chord progression on an acoustic guitar. Brent is a good guitar enough guitar player, and a good enough "local" singer. The lyrics in this one is where the song falls apart. As much as Brent wants to keep things simple, these lyrics are far too much so. This is a nice ode to the one he loves, but it should stay there -- with the one he loves.
Scoring: Songcraft: 5, Recording: 5, Freshness: 3, Vocals: 5, Musicianship: 7, XFactor: 5
|
Andy Chapman gave a score of 6.83 / 10. Comments were:
"Finding our way" is a really quite a beautiful balad, delivered with tenderness and sincerity. The recording is wonderful and clean, the lyrics are simple but thoughtful and the vocals are raw and effective. This isn't a radio single, but it is certainly a nice addition to any collection.
Scoring: Songcraft: 7, Recording: 7.5, Freshness: 6, Vocals: 6.5, XFactor: 6.5
|
Uncle Thumpy gave a score of 6.25 / 10. Comments were:
Beautiful tone and you voice is birdsong-sweet. +1 for vocals..and it would have been higher except for the off-notes the harmony line has early on in the song.
Fingerpicking feels a bit stiff here and there, and do I detect digital shifting on those lead vocals? -.5 to musicianship.
Losing half a point on recording for the backing vocal not sitting well with the lead. -.5 to Recording Quality.
The lyrics made me misty-eyed. Huge +4 to Lyrics.
Harry Chapin and Jim Croce would have been proud. +1 for Songwriting.
Even with the deductions, the whole is more than the sum of its parts. +2 on XFactor.
I this on iTunes? I'll *buy* it,
Scoring: Songcraft: 6, Recording: 4.5, Freshness: 5, Vocals: 6, Musicianship: 4.5, XFactor: 7
|
Nibbish gave a score of 8.75 / 10. Comments were:
With the glut of guitar-only singer-songwriters out there, it's easy to forget just how effective and powerful the genre can be when done right. 'Finding Our Way' does everything right. The acoustic guitar sounds beautiful, and Mr. Ratkovich's vocals are spot on by every definition of the word. The lyrics are simple, yet emotionally tinged. This song is simply fantastic. Kudos to you, Brent, you've created an amazing song.
Scoring: Songcraft: 9, Recording: 8.5, Freshness: 8.5, Vocals: 9, Musicianship: 8.5, XFactor: 9
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 7.16 / 10. Comments were:
Brent doing a good job. Nice fingerpickin', good vocals, nice flow. Remind Mongo of John Denver - for today Good mellow tune about the stuff that makes us all tick. Out of 10 bonez Mongo give 44
Scoring: Songcraft: 8, Recording: 7, Freshness: 7, Vocals: 7, Musicianship: 7.5, XFactor: 7
|
 |
Genre: Rock
|
|
nb gave a score of 5.41 / 10. Comments were:
The intro hey hey reminded me of the 70s bubblegum pop Bay City Rollers chant of S A T U R DAY night then you shifted gear into an edgier punkpop which was surprising but worked. Great energy, authentic feel nothing too original or outstanding just straight up r and r. Enjoyable listen all in all.
Scoring: Songcraft: 5.5, Recording: 5, Freshness: 5, Vocals: 6, Musicianship: 6, XFactor: 5.5
|
rottimom gave a score of 7.33 / 10. Comments were:
Good straight up rock here. Vocals were good. I have heard thousands of bands with this style, so there's nothing unique here. But, still a solid prformance from n obviously tight band.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6, Recording: 9, Freshness: 7, Vocals: 9, Musicianship: 9, XFactor: 7
|
Nibbish gave a score of 7.08 / 10. Comments were:
According to Buffalo Chrome, it's Rock and Roll Time - and I'd be inclined to agree. Rock and roll songs about rock and roll are probably as old as the genre itself, but it's always nice to hear a well done take on it, nonetheless. The recording quality is a bit... gritty, but the driving beat and hitting guitars barrel right past any obstacles that fact might put in their way. The vocalist is enthusiastic and up to the task. The lyrics are ridiculous and silly, but completely forgivable. When music is this fun, who needs depth?
Scoring: Songcraft: 7.5, Recording: 4.5, Freshness: 8, Vocals: 8, Musicianship: 7, XFactor: 8.5
|
Goat gave a score of 4.33 / 10. Comments were:
Okay. The boys can bang a gong. They can rock n roll. But didn't I hear this song like back in the 70s or something?
Scoring: Songcraft: 5, Recording: 5, Freshness: 3, Vocals: 5, Musicianship: 6, XFactor: 3
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 6 / 10. Comments were:
Don't smoke the buffalo. Good rock tune, doin all the chops but somehow remind Mongo of David Bowie meet AC/DC. Got a bit tedious for Mongo but then again Mongo old dude - has short term rememory loss. Still - this one has some smoke but needs original fire. Out of ten Bonez - Mongo give 7
Scoring: Songcraft: 6.5, Recording: 6, Freshness: 4.5, Vocals: 6.5, Musicianship: 7, XFactor: 6.5
|
Genre: Other
|
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 2.12 / 10. Comments were:
A rather special thing, with classical influences, and later a vocal. Nothing much else to say since the artist never gave me the whole song, but teased me with a sample. No more candy for me then. Well, I'll not share any of my candy with the artist either. So there.
Scoring: Songcraft: 4, Recording: 2.5, Freshness: 2, XFactor: 0
|
Nibbish gave a score of 6.2 / 10. Comments were:
Cabaret Noir? You've got me intruiged from the instant I get a glimpse of your website. I love the violin to start things off, with the guitar flaring in the background. Once things kick up a notch, they get interesting. I like the urgency of the vocals, as well as almost gypsy-like flourishes. I dislike mentioning sample MP3s, because it isn't really the song's fault, but in order for us to really give a fair, thorough rating, we need to at least hear the chorus (the sample given cuts out right at the chorus). Choruses make or break about 80% of songs, and having not heard the one to 'Living Round Here', I don't feel like I actually have a feel for the song. I liked what I heard, but I need to hear more.
Scoring: Songcraft: 7, Recording: 5.5, Freshness: 7, Vocals: 6.5, Musicianship: 7, XFactor: 5
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 9.5 / 10. Comments were:
Ensimble or encimbly - it is a rare thing when musical discipline meets soul, but the folks in picturebox have it both. The violin and Spanish weave a comfortable classical blanket - when suddenly the opera of the left of field enable appears. A rising upbeat dirg - of the drunken sailor lamenting days gone by - but more recent ones than faded from memory. Or was that mamory?
Great work - none the less.
Mongo Out
Scoring: Songcraft: 10, Recording: 10, Freshness: 9.5, Vocals: 9, Musicianship: 10, XFactor: 9.5
|
nb gave a score of 6.83 / 10. Comments were:
Spectacular gypsy violin by the campfire kind of intro to the tune. I was surprised by the passionate vocalist coming in so late I was expecting an instrumental piece. Too bad the song cut out it was creating quite a tremendous build would have like to see where it climaxed. Very interesting...
Scoring: Songcraft: 7.5, Recording: 5.5, Freshness: 7, Vocals: 7.5, Musicianship: 8, XFactor: 5.5
|
MYSTR Treefrog gave a score of 8 / 10. Comments were:
Oh man! Very deep and mysterious and like a mix of the DANSE MACABRE and the novel PEDRO PARAMO...whoa..mad gypsies unite and become wine soaked demon skinwalkers with Violas.
I LIKE>
Scoring: Songcraft: 8.5, Recording: 7, Freshness: 9, Vocals: 7, Musicianship: 9.5, XFactor: 8.5
|
 |
Genre: World
|
|
Nibbish gave a score of 6.12 / 10. Comments were:
Nature sounds greet us to start out 'The Oak and the Loch'. Soon, we hear an arrangement that sounds very much like it was inspired by the 'Final Fantasy' game soundtracks. The only problem I can see here is that the instruments sound mostly like MIDI synthesized ones, so that would put us somewhere around Final Fantasy VII. What's odd about this song is that it's almost impossible to score ithout knowing the artist's intent. If the video game sounding MIDI score was indeed the artist's intent, fantastic, job well done, the arrangement itself is engaging and pleasant. If this was supposed to sound like an actual orchestral score, then I don't think it's going to be fooling many. I'm giving the artist the benefit of the doubt, because I did enjoy the arrangement and the mood that the arrangement had, I just had a hard time not visualizing spiky-haired heroes walking across my television screen as I listened. I will say this, however - I would greatly enjoy to hear this with either a better synthesized string section, or better (but more unlikely) yet, a real string section and completely real instruments all around.
Scoring: Songcraft: 7, Recording: 3, Freshness: 7, XFactor: 7.5
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 9.25 / 10. Comments were:
The Oak and the Loch reminds me of many of the greatest soundtracks to games I've ever heard. Games like, Oblivion, Guild Wars, Age of Conan, Guild Wars, and Morrowind. Now you may think that: Wow, is The Oak and the Loch that good? Well, yes. Sure, you hear that the instruments aren't real, but I can forgive that. The talent behind this piece of music is outstanding, and if you are a writer for a game of some sort with some medieval plot, you should pay some attention to Bonamici. Maybe he has what it takes to put music in your game? Highly recommended listen.
Scoring: Songcraft: 9, Recording: 9.5, Freshness: 9, XFactor: 9.5
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 10 / 10. Comments were:
Bonamici is all about what is right with the World. The Oak and the Loch is just a lovely tune. Gentle, well written, a classic piece - must like the theme to Brigadoon. It is suck a pleasure to enter your gentle world. Mongo knows this place. What a good place to be. A world where folk appreciate the fact that they are even alive. What it is they have and all of those they love. Bless your soul and all of those who are with you. Love to see you - on the other side.
This is Beyond all the Bonez - the place where the Bonez rise.. Just flawless... and not that many ever get there...
Scoring: Songcraft: 10, Recording: 10, Freshness: 10, Musicianship: 10, XFactor: 10
|
nb gave a score of 6.25 / 10. Comments were:
Celtic flavoured and cinematic in scope this worldly instrumental piece paints images of ancient forests and lakes like the title suggests. Dreamy and ethereal, perfect for relaxing and resting. Nice work.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6.5, Recording: 6.5, Freshness: 6, Musicianship: 6.5, XFactor: 6
|
Axeman gave a score of 7.75 / 10. Comments were:
Not world, but very classical. Sounds like an enjoyable film score. The use of theme and development of same (without overdoing it) is outstanding. Very well composed. My only nit is to do away with the cute synth birds at start and finish. Id replace them with a real instrument, like a classical guitar or something.
Scoring: Songcraft: 9, Recording: 9, Freshness: 6, Musicianship: 8, XFactor: 7
|
Genre: Electronic
|
|
Nibbish gave a score of 4.91 / 10. Comments were:
"Woopsie-daisy", is how 'Wrong Way Out' starts out. For some reason, this grates on my nerves a bit, even more so when it turns out that it makes for an easy second couplet rhyme. The song itself is a dark electronica "ex slammer". The synth lines have nice groove to them, and the vocalist is a different sort than you normally hear, a much lower voice, less breathy. It sounds out of the ordinary, and serves the song nicely. Once the "I hear you scream and shout" line hits on the chorus, I was hoping that there could be some hope that the song would go the route of the dark revenge tale. Unfortunately, the only reason I can find for this lyric is that it rhymes with "wrong way out". Disappointing that many of the lyrics seem forcibly rhymed. I mean, almost all lyrical couplets have some manner of rhym to them, but these just all seem so... obvious. The "Whoopsie Daisy" line comes up two more times, sealing its fate. I dig the lower register female vocal, and the tune itself is decently solid, but the lyrics are just so stilted and silly that it's hard to recommend the song.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6, Recording: 7, Freshness: 6, Vocals: 7, XFactor: 2.5
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 8.5 / 10. Comments were:
"wrong way out" gets points for being a very different cup of tea. It might not be to everybody's taste, but that doesn't matter much. The song is well presented with good record quality, and great vocals. Would be great for radio. Recommended download.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6.5, Recording: 7.5, Freshness: 10, XFactor: 10
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 4.58 / 10. Comments were:
batu - wrong way out. Well named. nope. sorry. This don't do it for Mongo. This be electro-porno soundtrack. Maybe not even getting to that level. The structure is like camp-white- hipster. This just be canned tribal. Lot of skill at doing the wrong thing. Mongo know better could come out these folks
Scoring: Songcraft: 4, Recording: 9, Freshness: 3, Vocals: 6.5, Musicianship: 7, XFactor: 2
|
nb gave a score of 8.16 / 10. Comments were:
Electronic pop with mood appeal and a crisp and tasty vocalist with a style all her own to boot. Imagery deluxe and an atmospheric production that lifts this song above the rest. Wrong way out is a clever hook and you are on definitely on the right track here. I could not improve this hooky little ditty. Great song!
Scoring: Songcraft: 7.5, Recording: 7.5, Freshness: 8.5, Vocals: 9, Musicianship: 8, XFactor: 8.5
|
The Captain gave a score of 7.25 / 10. Comments were:
Batu's page contains the following promotional blurb: "Babusjka & Tublenco formed in blah blah blah when blah blah soundtrack blah blah blah blah and then blah blah ubercool and some more twang and porn blah blah, with blah on top." What a set up. But I can’t blah, blah the review, because their track 'The Wrong Way Out' actually has a very, very cool sound. The girl has a sensuous sound; the track has an infectious melody, featuring a trippy and ridiculous arrangement – one of those kinds that you will more likely hate than love, but (and here’s the point) you won’t easily forget it. Yeah, like a provocative pose; well arranged. Gotta give it to them this track is blah, blah interesting. (Couldn't resist that, sorry.) Recommended.
Scoring: Songcraft: 7.5, Recording: 7.5, Freshness: 7.5, Vocals: 7.5, Musicianship: 7, XFactor: 7
|
 |
Genre: Pop/Rock
|
|
nb gave a score of 7.58 / 10. Comments were:
Pure pop and ultra contagious chorus and hook well done! Nice transition and build into the chorus too. Tight and tasty production all radio ready. Vocally expressive, unique style and engages the listener immediately. Its all good. Best of luck with it!
Scoring: Songcraft: 8, Recording: 7.5, Freshness: 7.5, Vocals: 8.5, Musicianship: 8, XFactor: 7
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 8.3 / 10. Comments were:
Song in question wasn't present, so reviewing "think of me." Think of me is a powerful ballad, driven by great vocals, very good sound quality, and even better piano. Too bad I didn't get a chance to listen to Cloud Nine. But if it is anything as good as this . . . well . . . "think of me" gets my RECOMMENDED mark.
Scoring: Songcraft: 7, Recording: 7.5, Freshness: 7, XFactor: 10
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 9.08 / 10. Comments were:
Very good Mr K.C. Van Horn. Right on actually. Pop is that grate elusive beastie that many songwriters try to catch while others say why bother. But you've bothered and you've pretty much got it all hear. It has it's appeal to a certain slice of the pie but to that audience - that appeal you have captured. Well written, well structured, well played. Great Voice and backgrounds. On its way to being most excellent.
BEYOND THE BONEZ
Scoring: Songcraft: 9, Recording: 9, Freshness: 9.5, Vocals: 9, Musicianship: 9.5, XFactor: 9
|
Jonathan Sanders gave a score of 3.91 / 10. Comments were:
Sludgy guitars and keys open this, followed by Linkin Parkish vocals which come in quickly. They're not that good, and the lyrics are weak. The song as a whole fails to stand out. For pop, the hook is key, and the hook to this song is as weak as they come. Not recommended.
Scoring: Songcraft: 4, Recording: 6, Freshness: 4, Vocals: 3.5, Musicianship: 4.5, XFactor: 2.5
|
MYSTR Treefrog gave a score of 5.66 / 10. Comments were:
Standard niceboy modern rock. Vanilla...lots of it. The Bean has been crushed a liquified. This will win the high school battle of the bands.
Scoring: Songcraft: 5.5, Recording: 7, Freshness: 5, Vocals: 7, Musicianship: 6, XFactor: 4
|
 |
Genre: Pop/Rock
|
|
zkaplan gave a score of 4.83 / 10. Comments were:
"Weak" has a lot going for it in that Ms. Edmond is clearly talented, a good musician with good skills on the guitar and a pleasant, unfaltering voice. The song, however, leaves the listener wanting; it's something that would fit right in to the background of a cable television show about attractive young high school or college students who have complicated relationships with one another. In other words, "Weak" is well rounded and somewhat catchy, but nothing very interesting. It doesn't take us anywhere that we haven't been before musically, and the lyrics are especially forgettable and generic; by the end of the song they get quite repetitive. "You said your goodbyes/ I saw love in your eyes/ But you have made me weak." Apparently she's done something that he's making her feel especially guilty about, and now she's become emotionally weakened by the ordeal. But we learn little beyond this, and thus we are not especially interested and cannot connect on a personal level. The same vague ideas are repeated a few times, there's a short, pleasant, uncomplicated guitar solo, and it's back to the repetition, with generic music backing it up the whole time.
Overall it's catchy and pleasant yet unprovocative and bland. Very generic and not very memorable - not a terrible song, but nothing special.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6, Recording: 9, Freshness: 1, Vocals: 8, Musicianship: 8.5, XFactor: 3
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 4.37 / 10. Comments were:
Weak by Kylie Edmond is a half witted attempt by Kylie Edmond to make a radio friendly rock / pop diddly. Half witted, because everything sounds half finished. The vocals don't really punch through, the record quality is far from good. This in turn making the instruments sound bland and boring. The song has what it takes to make it, but needs a bit more work to really be the top hit we are "all" waiting for.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6.5, Recording: 5.5, Freshness: 5.5, XFactor: 0
|
Goat gave a score of 6.5 / 10. Comments were:
There's a new age of singer-songwriter who understands the new business paradigm --- that records are out, and synch/licensing deals are in. In that, new artists like Kyle understand their goal should be to get there music on tv shows in America. This is one of those songs. Perfectly suited for tv shows and movie soundtracks, where residual income is the new economy. Is it a good song? It's well performed, and it's suitably written. Is it a good song? That's up to you.
Scoring: Songcraft: 8, Recording: 8, Freshness: 5, Vocals: 8, Musicianship: 8, XFactor: 3
|
Nibbish gave a score of 6.58 / 10. Comments were:
Female fronted pop-rock music is a big thing right now, and there's a lot of mediocre artists trying to rush in to grab their piece of the radio play. Credit to Kylie Edmond, she isn't mediocre. 'Weak' is a solid tune, with lyrics that actually have a bit of substance (though they can be a bit cloying); decent, if not memorable backing music; and vocals that add a touch of twang (almost) to the mix. I could go for a little more edge to the song, but that's personal opinion. While this song isn't going to change the world as we know it, I'll still take it over a lot of what's on the radio right now.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6.5, Recording: 7, Freshness: 6, Vocals: 7, Musicianship: 5.5, XFactor: 6.5
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 9.08 / 10. Comments were:
This girl and the brothers behind her are jus "Smokin'". Great song writing, first cabin production - she believes it Brothers and Sister - this is the window we all strive to capture. There is an innocence with wisdom that unfolds in this marvelous tune. Does Mongos heart good to know that so many are finding their dreams - they way they were intended. And it is tunes such as "Weak" that helps others find theirs. Where was this Chick when Mongo was young? This be beyond the Bonez.
Scoring: Songcraft: 9, Recording: 8.5, Freshness: 9, Vocals: 9, Musicianship: 9.5, XFactor: 10
|
 |
Genre: Acid Jazz
|
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 8.83 / 10. Comments were:
John S Hofman just loves his guitar. And it shows as he makes love to it - His tune "Chareity" kicks it right through the pasely ladened space and time this tune envelopes. A bit like Prince before he changed his name - but less plastic and canned. Good vocals and piece structure - the raves would love it. His other tunes on My Space are quite good as well. Mongo Digs it. 10 Bonez
Scoring: Songcraft: 9, Recording: 9, Freshness: 8.5, Vocals: 9, Musicianship: 9.5, XFactor: 9
|
Nibbish gave a score of 3.91 / 10. Comments were:
'Charity' is an excercize in psychedelic walls of sound and stream-of-conciousness songwriting. After a mild begining, the song breaks loose - every guitarist suddenly starts doing different things with no indication from the vocalist (who sounds stoned) that we've reached any sort of turning point in the song. For the ADD afflicted among us, there's plenty to keep track of, from the solo guitar going to town in the background to the squall of guitar providing the foundation, to the vocalist, who keeps muttering incoherently about 'charity' (which makes sense, I suppose). The song ends up reading like the 4 minute middle of the world's longest run-on sentence. In doing so, it doesn't give the listener any bearing on how to take in any of it. There's certainly enjoyable parts to this sort of music, and the band certainly seems to be enjoying itself, it's jus thard not to wish things wee a touch more focused.
Scoring: Songcraft: 1.5, Recording: 3.5, Freshness: 5, Vocals: 4.5, Musicianship: 6.5, XFactor: 4
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 3.37 / 10. Comments were:
Charity has a sort of introduction, where everything is chaotic. It gets a bit better, but not much. Everything is all over the place, guitars, vocals, everything. Only the drum holds a steady beat throughout, so I guess only the guy or the girl on the drums was the only one who wasn't on some kind of substance or powder or pill or whatnot inside something else. In any case, this is a song which was either a tad too intelligent for me, or maybe I need some of the stuff that John S Hofman / JSH are on.
Scoring: Songcraft: 2, Recording: 7.5, Freshness: 4, XFactor: 0
|
Axeman gave a score of 3.5 / 10. Comments were:
The key to JSH's downfall can be found in his Myspace proclamation that he doesnt want fame or money, but only wants to Charitably share his "God-given" gift with the world. Word to JSH: this philosophy will be your ruin. Take it from someone who saw Vai and Satriani play in small clubs on Long Island.
But i digress..."Charity" might not be so bad if half of the tracks were erased. The trouble is that the mix is extremely muddy and sounds like two arena-rock songs mixed together. It really gets to be painful to the ears after a short while. Be charitable and please use compression on your tracks, and work toward simplification rather than complication. There's some good ideas here, but it needs to be rethought along the lines of pleasing the audience, rather than trying to be fauxly sophisticated.
Scoring: Songcraft: 3, Recording: 1, Freshness: 5, Vocals: 4.5, Musicianship: 7, XFactor: 5.5
|
nb gave a score of 4 / 10. Comments were:
I was disappointed to find that this was not acid jazz rather a pseudo 70s Boston influenced rock with abit of Axyl Rose vocal affect. Overuse of the fx making it sound contrived and like a basement tape. Muddled in construct both as songwriting and production. Perhaps the disappointment has affected my critique. Better luck next time.
Scoring: Songcraft: 4.5, Recording: 4, Freshness: 2.5, Vocals: 5.5, Musicianship: 5, XFactor: 4
|
 |
Genre: Electronic
|
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 0 / 10. Comments were:
Your Karma ran over your Dogma. No Linkie No Review-ie No Bone-ie
Scoring: Songcraft: 0, Recording: 0, Freshness: 0, XFactor: 0
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 7.62 / 10. Comments were:
This is regular fare from Karma. Electronic music with that extra spark to move it up above the regular junk I listen to. Way to go ! Recommended listen.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6.5, Recording: 8, Freshness: 8.5, XFactor: 7.5
|
Axeman gave a score of 6.62 / 10. Comments were:
Computer music is so ridiculously easy to produce these days, that it really takes something special to rise above the massive sea of mediocrity that can be found on the internet.
Karma Police almost succeeds at this, mainly by employing some very effective stereo panning that gives this tune a real three-dimensional effect. It's weakness is the driving house beat, which detracts from what is otherwise an innovative work. This would actually be pretty darn cool with some real drums thrown in the mix.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6, Recording: 8.5, Freshness: 6, Musicianship: 6, XFactor: 6
|
nb gave a score of 5.37 / 10. Comments were:
Ambient and dreamy in a retro sounding electronica nice sweeping pads and quiet contrasts moves the song along channging moods and landscapes.Tranquil in nature and more ambient than trance in the electronic side of things. Enjoyable piece.
Scoring: Songcraft: 5.5, Recording: 5.5, Freshness: 5, Musicianship: 6.5, XFactor: 5.5
|
Nibbish gave a score of 8.87 / 10. Comments were:
'Huge Universe' is a very nice, mellow trance-ish tune. The recording quality is spot on, the synths sound beautiful and spot on. The underlying beats and effects are interesting and tasteful, and at just under 5 minutes, the song doesn't overstay its welcome, as songs of this genre often do.
Simply put, this is a fantastic example of its genre, and should be listened to by anyone with an even passing interest in electronic music.
Scoring: Songcraft: 8.5, Recording: 9.5, Freshness: 8, XFactor: 9.5
|
 |
Genre: Electronic
|
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 8 / 10. Comments were:
Pretty good Electtonica. Nice breaks, more than three chords. Pretty good Vocals and nice structure. Could be the Soundtrack on some film being played on the IFC Channel Mongo think this one flys pretty well.
Eight Bonez
Scoring: Songcraft: 7.5, Recording: 8.5, Freshness: 8, Vocals: 8, Musicianship: 8.5, XFactor: 8.5
|
Nibbish gave a score of 7.58 / 10. Comments were:
Female vocals over chillout electronica beats might be the biggest cliche in music, but it's still a treat when it's done right. 'Numb' does it right, with a main melody line that live sup to the track's title. Just enough of a drum line to hold everything together, and (of course), the female vocal. Luckily for us listeners, she's a good vocalist, who puts emphasis in all the right places (this is key), and also is strong enough to not let the music overwhelm her (this is even more key). Little touches in the second half of the song (a little jazzy note here, a little effect for flair there) are just icing on the cake. I greatly enjoyed this song, and it simply goes to prove that talent can often times invigorate even the most tired cliche.
Scoring: Songcraft: 8.5, Recording: 8, Freshness: 7.5, Vocals: 8, XFactor: 7.5
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 8.25 / 10. Comments were:
This is an electronic song that very slowly builds itself up like most songs like this does. Numb surprises me though, because suddenly a beat, and a beautiful female vocal turn up out of nowhere. From there, it is only bliss. Very radio friendly. A nice crisp guitar even turns up by the end. Very enjoyable. Recommended listen.
Scoring: Songcraft: 10, Recording: 8, Freshness: 5, XFactor: 10
|
the720k gave a score of 7.5 / 10. Comments were:
"Numb" starts out with a beautiful, if simple, piano solo and transforms into a stellar example of trip-hop with a perfectly executed drumline. The vocals are full and dreamy, exuding of emotion. However, the vocal mix could use a little work, as the piano seems to overpower the vocals at times, and it's hard to hear what she's singing. The lyrics themselves seem a bit run-to-the-mill and don't particularly strike me as extraordinary, although they are not out of place.
The guitar that comes in during the latter half of the song is warm and well-mixed, and adds a nice extra layer of organic sound to the selection.
Overall, I enjoyed this track and would certainly listen to it again. This is an excellent example of the genre, and I would like to hear more!
Scoring: Songcraft: 7.5, Recording: 7.5, Freshness: 6.5, Vocals: 8, Musicianship: 7.5, XFactor: 9
|
nb gave a score of 6.16 / 10. Comments were:
Nice blending of pop and electronica, The soprano is genteel and angelic.The break beats funk it up and the pads help the flow.Ethereal and haunting with longing qualities a very enjoyable listen.
Scoring: Songcraft: 6, Recording: 6.5, Freshness: 6, Vocals: 6.5, Musicianship: 6.5, XFactor: 6
|
 |
Genre: Christian Pop/Rock
|
|
Nibbish gave a score of 7.16 / 10. Comments were:
Often times, Christian Pop-Rock can be expected to have a very sanitary view on issues (often coupled with very cookie cutter macking music). Mike Kovacevich turns the tables on both of these stereotypes with 'Battle', and provides the listener with a breath of fresh air - a solid, non-trite song about everyday struggles and personal demons. The recording qualty is quite good, and the guitar playing is done quite well, with some subtle percussion laying a good foundation for Kovacevich's vocals and lyrics. Speaking of lyrics, these are actual good quality lyrics that dig into spiritual matters without sounding contrived or fake. Well done.
Scoring: Songcraft: 7.5, Recording: 7.5, Freshness: 7.5, Vocals: 6, Musicianship: 8, XFactor: 7
|
MongoKnowsRecords gave a score of 6.5 / 10. Comments were:
Mike and his Boyz are surely trying. Laying down a tune they feel is important - trying to tell us something that they believe really matters. And it does .. but its all relative to the one fighting it. Takes awhile to get to the story here - the musical intro is way to long. And though there is skill - there is to much wall of sound going on for Mongo's ears. And the singer gets lost in the wave. Less can be more..
Out of ten Bonez - Mongo give four
Scoring: Songcraft: 7, Recording: 7, Freshness: 6.5, Vocals: 6.5, Musicianship: 6.5, XFactor: 6
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 3.12 / 10. Comments were:
The artist, Mike, probably thought this to himself before making this song: Wow, how many plonks on the guitar can I fit on an mp3 file? Hmm. Let's try 6, or 7 at the same time shall we? And not only that, let's bend them and twist them to make them even more annoying. Let's make all those ploinks battle each other to see who wins! Yes! Great idea!!" << Well, something like that. Because>> The intro of this song is just dreadful. All these strokes on the guitar are bended, to create a sort of effect, of sorts. The problem is, it DOES NOT work. it sort of gets a little better when the artist starts to sing. But the good record quality can't fight away the ploings, and plinks which return a little later. For a vengeance! And those awful things are still totally out of tune with everything else. Oh Jesus no. Sorry. Next time, leave the ploinks in their cage, and let the beautiful music unfold instead.
Scoring: Songcraft: 3.5, Recording: 5, Freshness: 3.5, XFactor: 0.5
|
seedsower gave a score of 6.66 / 10. Comments were:
Just someting lacking
Scoring: Songcraft: 5, Recording: 8, Freshness: 7, Vocals: 7.5, Musicianship: 7, XFactor: 5
|
Mike Kovacevich gave a score of 7.41 / 10. Comments were:
OK, I'm going to go ahead and totally break the rules here; I'm reviewing my own song! Why in the world would I do something that stupid... well, my day job consists of administering surveys where individuals ask there peers, managers, and direct reports to rate their work performance. Typically these participants (as we call them) do a self-evaluation as well.
I always find it somewhat embarrassing when the self-score is way higher than everyone else’s. I think, man is he in for a surprise when he gets the results back!
So here we go. Lets see what kind of surprise awaits me!
First off, there is no way I can pretend to hear this song anew. I did listen to it as I would any other song I plan on reviewing but after writing and rewriting, recording and rerecording, mixing and remixing, I'm probably on my thousandth listen, and what amazes me the most is that I still love this song!
If I had it to do all over, I would probably lighten up on the kick and snare a little, maybe have more of a conga feel. Maybe I'd thin out some of the background music but overall I'm very happy with the mix and arrangement. I love how the song breathes. All the stops and starts draw me in and make the song interesting.
I'm not a big fan of my voice, very self-conscious. Say something about my vocals and I'll walk away with my tail between my legs. Say something about my guitar playing and I’ll smile politely and not give it a second thought. I’m not saying I’m a great guitarist, I’m saying I don’t care that much if people like it or not. In this case though, I do think my vocals do the song justice. I like some of the falsetto work I do in the background. The lyrics are as raw and real as I can make them. Lyrically, I think it’s some of my finest work.
I’m pleased with the arrangement. Although from a commercial standpoint, it doesn’t have a big hook that repeats several times. As I now try to market my work, I question if the lack of repetition was the wisest move… hmmm. Regardless, I think the pace is good, always moving forward. The end was definitely the hardest part of song to write and mix. It’s not perfect but I am happy with the intensity, and bigness of it.
Overall, I think this is a powerful, well-crafted song, one of my best.
And now on with the other four reviews to put me in my place…
Although, while I’m at it, if you agree, disagree, or have your own take on this song (which I’m sure you do) please visit my web site and tell me about it. I’d love to hear your thoughts.
Scoring: Songcraft: 7, Recording: 8, Freshness: 8, Vocals: 6, Musicianship: 7.5, XFactor: 7
|
Genre: Country
|
|
Nibbish gave a score of 6.41 / 10. Comments were:
'Older' is a little more 'Americana' than country, with a certain earthy feel to it. The first thing one notices is that this recording quality is on the low end. It doesn't kill the song, but it makes it harder for it to truely stand out. The vocals seem a little undermixed, but the singer has a certain charm to him that ends up being able to transcend those mixing issues. During the wordless bridges , the song stalls a little. It's not until the horns are added that the song gains back that 'something' that it seemed to be missing to that point. I like the horns a lot, they raise the bar for this song and make it a lot better. This is exactly the type of rootsy Americana that I can appreciate. It doesn't break a lot of new ground, and the recording quality dings the lasting appeal a bit, but it's got a real good laid back feel, and has a wistful, summertime mood to it.
Scoring: Songcraft: 8, Recording: 3.5, Freshness: 6, Vocals: 6.5, Musicianship: 6.5, XFactor: 7
|
Christian Lowensprung gave a score of 6.8 / 10. Comments were:
Reviewing Mr. Goodtimes as "older" was unavailable. Mr. Goodtimes, starts off rather ugly, but it becomes apparent that there is some real talent behind this music. The song takes some different turns and twists throughout the song, and the lyrics are really wonderful. A bit better record quality, and the overall impression would be much better. Recommended listen.
Scoring: Songcraft: 8, Recording: 2.5, Freshness: 5.5, XFactor: 10
|
seedsower gave a score of 5.41 / 10. Comments were:
The style of music sounded to hippy
Scoring: Songcraft: 5, Recording: 4.5, Freshness: 7.5, Vocals: 6, Musicianship: 6.5, XFactor: 5
|
nb gave a score of 5.08 / 10. Comments were:
This went to Miracle Cure. An experimental countrified violin meets blind melon and twinges of a sci fi 50s keys sort of thing. Other is an apt genre for this tune, I am not sure if this should be taken seriously or if comedy. I think radio would have hard time with it. Unusual for sure.
Scoring: Songcraft: 5.5, Recording: 4, Freshness: 5, Vocals: 6, Musicianship: 5, XFactor: 5
|
Axeman gave a score of 4.41 / 10. Comments were:
The song needs compression, the volume is uneven. I liked the keyboards in the background, but the guitar grated on me. I got a little bored by the end, but that could be because it's 6 am.
Scoring: Songcraft: 5, Recording: 3, Freshness: 4.5, Vocals: 5, Musicianship: 5, XFactor: 4.5
|
|
|
Login
Click here to login.
Join
Join our reviewing team.
Artists sign up here.
Blog
Read our Blog
Top 5 Reviewers:
Christian Lowensprung
MongoKnowsRecords
nb
Nibbish
Goat
Our Stats:
Reviews Published: 1155
Requests In Queue: 980
Average Score: 5.64
Powered by SIMB Web Design Melbourne
|
